Ship of Theseus
From Freepedia
The Ship of Theseus is a replacement paradox also known as Theseus's paradox.
According to Greek legend as reported by Plutarch,
- "The ship wherein Theseus and the youth of Athens returned [from Crete] had thirty oars, and was preserved by the Athenians down even to the time of Demetrius Phalereus, for they took away the old planks as they decayed, putting in new and stronger timber in their place, insomuch that this ship became a standing example among the philosophers, for the logical question of things that grow; one side holding that the ship remained the same, and the other contending that it was not the same."
There is also an additional question: if the replaced parts were stored in a warehouse and later used to reconstruct the ship, which—if either—would be the original ship of Theseus?
Contents |
A modern embellishment
If Theseus paid a nontransferable fee, allowed to be used for only one ship, for the privilege of docking in a particular harbor, would he violate the non-transferability of his license if repeated replacement of boards eventually had the result described above?
The philosophical point of this example is that it sometimes makes sense to regard an object's identity as the same for a particular purpose even if it might be different from some other purpose.
Heraclitus
The Greek philosopher Heraclitus took an opposing view of metaphysical identity by stating "No man can cross the same river twice, because neither the man nor the river are the same."
USS Constitution
A modern day example of such a ship is the USS Constitution, of which everything except the keel has been replaced.
George Washington's axe
A similar story is told about George Washington's axe, with which the young George Washington is supposed, in an apocryphal story, to have cut down his father's cherry tree. The axe is supposedly on display in an (unverifiable) American museum, although, having had both its handle and its head replaced several times, no part of the original axe remains.
The Tin Woodman's story
L. Frank Baum played with this paradox in The Wonderful Wizard of Oz. At one point the book tells the story of a lumberjack named Nick Chopper. One day a witch cast a spell on Nick's axe, and it cut off his leg. He proceeded to get the leg replaced with a tin prosthetic leg, only to have the enchanted axe chop off the other. He then replaced that missing leg with a tin prosthetic, only to have the process repeat itself with both his arms, torso, and eventually head. By the end of the ordeal, Nick was entirely made out of tin replacements, yet still living, and had become the Tin Man. In a later book, the paradox is further satirized when the Tin Man meets his old flesh body parts, which have been re-assembled with magic glue. Nick's former girlfriend is not sure whom to love.
Airplanes
Every aircraft has an attached metal "data plate" stamped with sufficient information to uniquely identify that aircraft. If an aircraft crashes and the data plate is recovered from the wreck, the entire structure of the aircraft may be rebuilt from new or spare parts and it will still be legally considered to be the same aircraft as long as it carries the same "data plate".
Automobiles
A similar situation exists with automobile Vehicle Identification Numbers. Each automobile is identified with a unique number inscribed in various locations, and this number is associated with the vehicle's legal registration. However, any number of parts can be replaced and it will still be considered to be the same vehicle. In some cases, an antique or desirable wrecked vehicle will be "repaired" by having its identification markers transferred to a new vehicle.
This is especially common in the cases of vehicles like the Volkswagen Beetle or Mini which remained in production for many years and have become collectable. Although such alteration was looked down on by enthusiasts and governments, at least one American company specialized in importing Beetles from Mexico to be resold as antique (and thus street- and emissions-legal) models.
On April 7, 2005, Boyd Coddington, famed hot rod designer and star of the American Discovery Channel television program American Hot Rod, pleaded guilty of perpetrating this type of fraud. Coddington's hot rods had been registered as antique automobiles in order to avoid emissions and tax liabilities. However, many of the vehicles no longer contained any parts from the original cars, and some were entirely unrelated to their supposed donor vehicles.
Digital rights management
Digital rights management systems, with hardware fingerprint lockout mechanisms, consider a computer with replaced parts (depending on the settings) to be a different computer. Consequently, it requires a license "reactivation", license transfer, or even new license for the computer in order for the protected software to continue operating on the computer.
Human identity
Beyond applications in modern technology, with the increasing potential of cosmetic surgery, organ transplants, genetic engineering and even cloning (not to mention the natural replacement and addition of cells in the body,) to change the shape of a human being, the Ship of Theseus paradox may increasingly apply to ourselves as well. At which point will medical alterations of a human being start to affect its identity? Philosophers like Descartes have postulated, "I think, therefore I am" (cogito ergo sum), which in this context can be regarded as an assertion that the human mind and consciousness is what is shaping our identity. Under this premise, a clone, while having the same physical shape down to genetic level, will not be the same person. Only surgical alterations of the human brain could affect our identity in this regard (personality).
One might argue, however, that in light of the tendency of people to assess things and persons based upon their physical appearance, the everyday life understanding of human identity is going further. If "body and mind" are both equal aspects of human identity, the intentional, temporary or permanent change of the former that is common in modern society can be regarded as a change of identity already.
Rock groups
The same phenomenon can be seen in rock and pop bands, such as the Drifters and Napalm Death which sometimes contain none of the original members of the band. A complementary version of this is Yes, former members of which formed two bands that both claimed the name 'Yes'.
Sports teams
The same phenomenon can also be seen in many sports teams, when team members, managers, and even home cities can change from season to season. The Baltimore Orioles of the 1950s are quite different from the same team today.
Computer modifications
And again, another example can be seen while upgrading computers. If you gradually replace every component of a system over time, including the case, does the resulting PC still remain the original PC? Would it still seem this way if the original parts were then reassembled?
Only Fools and Horses BBC TV
In one episode of Only Fools and Horses, Trigger proudly displays a medal to anyone who will look which he was awarded by the local council for having contributed to the community by using the same brush for the past 20 years. He then proudly holds up the brush and claims "Maintained it for 20 years. This old broom's had 17 new heads and 14 new handles in its time." When Sid inquires how it can be classed as the same brush, Trigger angrily shows him a picture of him receiving the medal and demands "Well there's the bloody picture! What more proof do you need?"
